Hey Rob,
I was a little nervous myself when I'd originally noticed the changes. However, all appears to be normal...well, except for a some pricing changes. We have just returned (last Sunday) from our first Transatlantic on the QM2...and all I can say is....WOW! We were so impressed that we've (just today) booked another vacation on her. The 12 night "Autumn Colors", in October 2013. We have decided to forfeit a sheltered balcony stateroom this trip, in order to make it a little more affordable. In any case, while pricing staterooms last night we did take notice that the sheltered balcony staterooms are now considered a higher grade, as compared with staterooms on deck 8 (with obstructed views). To be honest, my family and I were extremely impressed with the overall size of our sheltered balcony. My parents were a little reluctant about the idea of the balcony being sheltered, but quickly grew on them. They look to be slightly larger than the balconies provided on Deck 8, perhaps even Decks 11 and 12 as well. Maybe guests were complaining about paying higher fares for balcony cabins with obstructed views/less room...and so we the categories were switched around? As I was unable to sail aboard QE2 before her retirement, I cannot give a comparison of both liners. However, cruising for most of my life it was wonderful to be aboard a true ocean liner.
Take Care!
CJ